news

This Recent Punishment By A School Was Deemed "Too Harsh" By Parents

The incident purportedly happened at a school in Taman Tun Dr Ismail, Kuala Lumpur.

Cover image via Harian Metro

A group of parents have expressed their dissatisfaction after their children were made to sit on tar road for being late to school

Image via Harian Metro

Following the widespread sharing of photos of students sitting on the tarred road in a school compound on social media, parents of these students have complained that their children did not deserve such punishment from the school authorities.

It is believed that the incident took place at SMK Taman Tun Dr Ismail, Kuala Lumpur.

According to one of the student's relative who declined to be named, the incident happened on Monday, 7 November

Image via Harian Metro

"When I asked why the students were treated in that way, the principal stated that students who were late had to be isolated from other students."

"The principal then said that since there was not enough space during the school assembly, they had no other choice but to sit on the road," the relative was quoted as saying by Malay daily Harian Metro.

"The principal said, they (students) have also been instructed to bring the plastic coverings should they be late to school."

"I asked whether there was any other way than sitting on the road because the students wear the same clothes for prayer, fearing that they may sit on dirt and others."

"But the principal seemed to be insinuating when he said that parents can donate more than 1,000 chairs to ensure that their children can sit on the benches during assembly."

National Parent-Teacher Association (PIBGN) chairman Prof Datuk Dr Mohd Ali Hassan said that the punishment was too harsh and not justified

Image via Harian Metro

"The principal should have exercised discretion when it comes to disciplining students."

"The psychological and emotional aspects of students should be taken into account instead of just focusing on imposing punishments and so on," he told Harian Metro.

He said students should be warned in advance and they should not continue to be treated as such.

However, many people have opined that the issue has been blown out of proportion and that students were too pampered

Image via Facebook

Do you think the school was being too harsh in punishing students who come late to school? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below.

In April, a teacher repeatedly hit his student with a chair, fracturing the student's right hand:

Speaking of which, those who used to be mischievous in school will surely remember some of these punishments they went through:

Leave a comment