news

[INFOGRAPHIC] A-G Exposes: RM3 Mill For Missing Paintings & More

The Auditor General Report 2013 revealed another full account of the Malaysian budget wasted, lost and mismanaged. Where did the money go to?

Cover image via

INFOGRAPHIC: Highlights from the Auditor General's Report 2012

INFOGRAPHIC: Highlights from the Auditor General's Report 2012. Image from The Star.

Image via imgur.com

Khazanah Nasional Berhad spent RM3.05 million on 55 paintings that were never exhibited

Khazanah Nasional Berhad spent RM3.05 million on 55 paintings that were never exhibited

Image via akamaihd.net

AUDITOR General Tan Sri Ambrin Buang has admonished Khazanah Nasional Berhad for not exhibiting or storing properly procured paintings valued at RM3.05 million.
Some 55 paintings acquired for that sum, some bought as far back as 2005, had not been
exhibited or stored properly, said the Auditor General’s Report 2012 tabled yesterday in the Dewan Rakyat.

theborneopost.com

Ministry of Communication spent RM3.19 million on 'School Children' program that does not exist

School Children campaign

Image via akamaihd.net

Putrajaya spent RM100million over 3 years for the Prime Minister's private jet

Putrajaya spent RM100million over 3 years for the Prime Minister's private jet

Image via akamaihd.net

RM100 Juta Digunakan untuk Jet Peribadi Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Najib Razak

terbakor.com

Putrajaya spent RM100million over 3 years for the Prime Minister's private jet

Image via freemalaysiatoday.com

Putrajaya spends RM28.8 million in annual rental and RM5.5 million to maintain the VVIP government jet ACJ319, the private aircraft used to ferry prime ministers much like the Air Force One in the US.

yahoo.com

From 2010, the government has spent RM86.4 million on rental of the private jet and RM16.515 million on maintenance. An additional RM 3.32 million was spent on refurbishing.
Over three years, a total of RM100.47 million was spent on the private jet.

freemalaysiatoday.com

Since 2008, on top of the private jet spending, an additional RM44.02 million was spent on the Prime Minister’s overseas travels.

freemalaysiatoday.com

Putrajaya spent RM330,000 for 'Endless Possibilities' campaign

Putrajaya spent RM330,000 to come up with its "Endless Possibilities" campaign and has insisted that the slogan was not copied from other countries, as has been alleged.

themalaysianinsider.com

Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Datuk Seri Shahidan Kassim said the amount was for the entire campaign and not just for the slogan alone.

themalaysianinsider.com

Taman Dusun Bandar project used RM17.25 million

Taman Dusun Bandar project used RM17.25 million

Image via blogspot.com

The controversial Taman Dusun Bandar project in Jalan Bellamy was deemed a failure by the auditor-general. An audit visit on September 27 last year revealed that the park had not been opened to the public despite it being completed by the contractor on April 30, 2010.

yahoo.com

The Auditor-General’s Report 2012 revealed the RM17.25 million project undertaken by contractor Zikhtar Associates Sdn Bhd was done through direct negotiations not approved by the Finance Ministry.

yahoo.com

The Federal Government debt is RM519,304 as of 30 September 2013

The Federal Government debt is RM519,304 as of 30 September 2013

Image via akamaihd.net
Unsupported video platform

Our Federal Government DEBT as of the 2nd Quarter ( 2Q ) of this year 2013 was officially reported at RM519BILLION... up by RM11 Billion from the previous report.

bnm.gov.my

The Auditor General report 2012

The 2013 Auditor General’s Report brings to the fore shocking and totally unacceptable cases of wastage, suspicious deals, losses and incidents screaming of a scam, mismanagement and absolute indifference to nation, King and rakyat.

malaysia-chronicle.com

Each year the Auditor General’s Report raises more than eyebrows. Yet, we let all things be, and soon the wastage, mismanagement and lack of accountability is forgiven and forgotten.

malaysia-chronicle.com

Youth and Sports Ministry paid RM1.6 million for K-pop artists during the 2012 National Youth Day celebrations

Hari Belia 2012 expenditure

Image via googleusercontent.com

The Youth and Sports Ministry paid up to RM1.6 million to bring in three K-pop artists for the National Youth Day celebrations last year, according to the Auditor-General’s Report 2012.

malaysiakini.com

A total of RM1.11 million was spent on promotion and publicity for the event, which the auditor-general describes as being too high. Other expenses similarly classified were two separate payments of RM50,000 to 50 bloggers for promotion and publicity.

blogspot.com

The auditor-general also complains about the manner in which the ministry had spent RM42,500 to purchase robot signboards. Another RM48,300 was spent on a 'working visit' to Institut Kemahiran Belia Negara in Jitra, then to Songkhla, Phuket and Krabi in Thailand.

blogspot.com

Malaysian Youth paid up to RM430,000 for the same job multiple times

The Auditor-General’s Department found that the Malaysian Youth Council (MBM) made multiple payments for the same job more than once.

thestar.com.my

In its 2012 report, it found that the MBM made between 2 and 3 payments for the same job on 6 different occasions, and labelled these "improper payments". The payments varied between RM26,500 and RM41,000, totaling RM430,000.

thestar.com.my

In response, the Department said it sent a letter to MBM to get back the RM220,900 excess payments paid to M&S Event & Resources (RM186,300) and Khaliff Enterprise (RM34,600).

thestar.com.my

Health Ministry spent RM320,000 on 2 Facebook and 1 Twitter accounts

Health Ministry spent RM320,000 on 2 Facebook and 1 Twitter accounts

Image via akamaihd.net

A breakdown of how much social media costs to setup, manage, and execute for any business looking to get into the world of Facebook and Twitter.

bluecloudsolutions.com

Outsourcing your social media isn't cheap, but it can pay off in the end. Here's how to determine your ROI.

contentfac.com

The auditor-general has questioned the Health Ministry’s payment of RM320,000 to two companies to enhance its social media presence by developing two Facebook and Twitter accounts.

malaysiakini.com

Eficaz Media charged RM199,068 for the “Tak Nak” Facebook campaign and Astonish View delivered a combined Facebook and Twitter effort on non-communicable diseases for RM120,500.

themalaymailonline.com

Eficaz Media was appointed for the period of July to Dec 2011 and that full payment was made based on the number of ‘Likes’ recorded on the FB page, set at 100,000. However, by July 2012, the number of ‘Likes’ had diminished by 3.58 percent or 3,460.

limkitsiang.com

Health Ministry spends RM320k on FB, Twitter

Image via imgur.com

Health Ministry paid RM 38,750 for 'stupid' anti-smoking campaign materials that were not distributed

The Health Ministry’s decision to brand smokers as ‘stupid’ in promotional literature cost it RM38,750 after the material was deemed unsuitable for distribution.

malaysiakini.com

Health Ministry’s ‘stupid’ campaign

Image via imgur.com

The health ministry had ordered 300 backpacks costing 3,500 notepads each at close to RM 20,000 with the slogan 'Smoking, a stupid habit for stupid people'. But the items never made it into the hands of the citizens as the language was later deemed inappropriate.

yahoo.com

The report also notes that 63,000 of the ministry's campaign posters worth more than RM31,200 had spelling mistakes.

malaysiakini.com

The ministry, in its reply, said it has since appointed an editorial team to check all its campaign materials and that it would also refer to Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka for advice.

malaysiakini.com
Unsupported video platform

Health Ministry staff submitted fake claims in excess of RM219,000 for uniforms

Health Ministry staff filed dubious claims totalling more than double the market price for the tailoring of long sleeve tops and pants, backed by receipts from outlets that did not exist, the Attorney-General (AG) report revealed.

themalaysianinsider.com

They also submitted claims in excess of RM200,000 for shoes, RM8,000 to RM9,000 for overcoats and up to RM2,800 for baju kurung. On top of that, since March last year, the ministry's staff were entitled to a RM150 claim for shoes, also by submitting an official receipt.

themalaysianinsider.com

The report noted that 922 staff from 10 hospitals, health departments and other health ministry divisions submitted fictitious claims totalling RM545,105 for the tailoring of long sleeve tops and long pants, when the market price is between RM146,340 and RM200,780.

themalaysianinsider.com

Royal Malaysian Police Force lost 309 items amounting up to RM1.33 million

Royal Malaysian Police Force lost 309 items amounting up to RM1.33 million

Image via akamaihd.net

Royal Malaysian Police Force lost 309 items amounting up to RM1.33 million

Image via themalaysianinsider.com

Royal Malaysian Police Force lost 309 items amounting up to RM1.33 million

Image via mkini.net

Tan Sri Khalid Abu Bakar said today that the missing guns highlighted in the just-released federal audit had not fallen into the wrong hands but could have “fallen into the sea”, as he deflected criticisms against the police force for lacking accountability.

themalaymailonline.com

Some RM1.3mil in assets, including firearms, vehicles and handcuffs were lost by police over the last three years, according to the the 2012 Auditor-General’s report presented to Parliament Tuesday.

thestar.com.my

PDRM bought five aircrafts costing RM175.24 million, but it was hardly used

Between June 2008 and December 2010, the Malaysian police purchased five Beechcraft King Air 350 aircraft for a whopping US$58.25 million (RM175.24 million) for their Air Wing.

malaysiakini.com

PDRM bought five aircrafts costing RM175.24 million, but it was hardly used

Image via imgur.com

The planes were supposed to facilitate the upgrading of the nation’s air security. Out of the five, only three aircraft have been delivered so far.

limkitsiang.com

The planes were supposed to facilitate the upgrading of the nation’s air security. However, within less than five years of usage, one of the planes had to be grounded for eight months, while another could not be used between June and November 2012.

malaysiakini.com

The Home Ministry reported that the planes had to be grounded as a result of lack of financial allocation, as the Police Air Wing would continuously use components from the grounded aircraft as spare parts for other aircraft.

limkitsiang.com

Broadcasting Department went 7,200 times over budget with RM120,210 worth of clocks and scanners

Broadcasting Department went 7,200 times over budget with RM120,210 worth of clocks and scanners

Image via akamaihd.net
Image via imgur.com

The Broadcasting Department blew its budget spending RM120,210 on clocks and scanners alone, thus overpaying for these items by thousands of times beyond its actual cost.

themalaysianinsider.com

Despite budgeting RM100 per unit for a clock and RM200 per unit for an A4-sized document scanner, the Auditor-General found that the Broadcasting Department spent RM3,810 per unit for “branded” wall clocks and RM14,670 per unit for the scanners.

themalaysianinsider.com

Communications and Culture Ministry's travel claims for study trips were RM303,813 when it was worth RM50,000

Communications and Culture Ministry's travel claims for study trips were RM303,813 when it was worth RM50,000

Image via akamaihd.net

The Auditor-General's (AG) report revealed a total of RM27.59 million of unreasonable fee and overpayments under the Malaysian Emergency Services (MERS) 999.

Image via akamaihd.net

The Auditor-General questioned a RM303,813 travel claim by a Communications and Culture Ministry senior officer for a four-day study trip to Geneva, Switzerland, which the auditors felt was worth only RM50,000.

themalaysianinsider.com

The report also pointed out that the ministry overpaid for various charges, with the auditor-general’s office unable to verify the claims since no receipts were given.

themalaysianinsider.com

The claim was made by the officer as part of the ministry’s Malaysian Emergency Response Services (MERS) 999 project by Telekom Malaysia (TM).

themalaysianinsider.com

TM was paid RM6.7 million for media publicity and school programmes to educate children about the MERS 999 system. The only problem was that the programme was cancelled in October 2008 but TM still charged the ministry for it.

themalaysianinsider.com

Malacca Customs spent RM71.13 million to built the Immigration Quarantine Complex (CIQ) on private land, leading to a costly legal battle

The RM73 million Malacca Customs and Immigration Quarantine Complex (CIQ) was illegally built on private land which eventually cost the Malacca state government RM10.8 million, according to the Auditor-General’s Report 2012.

malaysiakini.com

There was a legal tussle between the land owner and the Malaccan government. The project was halted, restarted, terminated and restarted again.

limkitsiang.com

By the time the project was restarted, with a new contractor appointed on July 28, 2010, the cost had skyrocketed by over RM40 million to RM73 million. Up to May 2012, a total of RM71.13 million had been spent on the project.

malaysiakini.com

Customs Department destroyed RM602,089 worth of new shoes because they did not fit

Customs Department destroyed RM602,089 worth of new shoes because they did not fit

Image via akamaihd.net

The latest Auditor-General’s report has given a kick in the shins to the Customs Department for destroying 7,659 pairs of new footwear – because the shoes did not fit.

themalaysianinsider.com

Customs Department destroyed 7,659 pairs of new footwear

Image via imgur.com

In another case involving the Customs Department, the report stated that RM602,089 worth of shoes bought for its staff were destroyed because of wrong specification.

thestar.com.my

Gerik Community College paid RM85,500 for 1 unit of CCTV that could have cost RM10,249

Prices of goods may differ from one place to another, but when it comes to a DVR16 close circuit television system (CCTV), the Auditor-General’s 2012 Report finds the price difference between two places too big to swallow.

malaysiakini.com

According to the report, a unit of the DVR 16 CCTV purchased by the Gerik Community College in Perak cost more than eight times what its counterpart paid for in Masjid Tanah, Malacca.

malaysiakini.com

One unit in Gerik cost RM85,500 the one in Masjid Tanah cost RM10,249.
The CCTVs were installed as part of a bigger project to upgrade 15 community colleges throughout Malaysia, costing a total of RM50.17 million.

malaysiakini.com

Maintenance was also an issue, the report says, with one CCTV unable to capture images clearly as it was covered with bird droppings, while another had stopped recording because its disc was full.

malaysiakini.com

Registrar of Societies (ROS) spent RM121,090 on the eRoses system that was later terminated

Based on the Auditor General’s Report 2012, the Registrar of Societies (ROS) eRoses system was a waste as the system was not yet up and running despite the ROS having paid RM121,090 for it.

thestar.com.my

RM121,090 went down the drain although the system was only 30 per cent completed. RoS had a signed a RM850,000 contract with the contractor, Scot Technology (M) Sdn Bhd, to set up the system on Dec 31, 2008.

nst.com.my

The contract expired on June 30, 2009. The Home Ministry terminated the contract after the contracter failed to complete the work on time on Oct 29, 2009.

thestar.com.my

National Solid Wastes Management Department spent RM199 million on incinerators that did not operate for years

The National Solid Wastes Management Department (JPSPN) spent RM199 million on incinerators over the last four years, and then found there was no expertise to operate such machines in Malaysia.

malaysiakini.com

And even after completion, the Auditor-General's 2012 Report says, three of the incinerators were not operated for 223 to 642 days, all because of the lack of expertise. A fifth incinerator planned for Labuan was scrapped.

newsxs.com

Meanwhile, garbage piled up outside the incinerators. The Pahang government alone spent nearly RM1 million last year to clean up the mess the old way, the report said.

malaysiakini.com

Syarikat Prasarana Negara gave hundreds of millions in bonuses to its employees despite making losses of RM763 million

The Auditor-General Report today stated that Syarikat Prasarana Negara, an infrastructure company which had the highest recorded deficit of RM763 million among the group, gave its employees between one-and-a-half and two months bonus each.

themalaysianinsider.com

Amanah Raya gave a RM1,000 bonus to each employee despite recording a RM707 million loss. Jambatan Kedua gave one month’s bonus despite its RM42 million loss. IWK distributed one-and-a-half months to two months bonus despite a RM98 million loss and Cyberview gave out two-and-a-half months bonus although it made a RM254 million deficit.

themalaysianinsider.com

The report also found that MIMOS, the country’s research centre, was the most generous of the group, by giving out between two and three months bonus to its employees, despite making a RM4.6 million loss in 2011.

themalaysianinsider.com

Meanwhile, employees of KTM received the least, with the railway operator distributing ex-gratia payments of a half-month’s salary or a minimum of RM500 in the same year. The company made losses of RM103 million.

themalaysianinsider.com

Welfare Departments nationwide are distributing welfare aid to hundreds of dead people

Dead people were receiving welfare aid in Sabah, Kelantan and Negeri Sembilan. This is yet another finding in the 2012 Auditor-General’s Report, which highlighted spectacular failures by government departments when it was submitted to Parliament yesterday.

themalaysianinsider.com

Under standard operating procedures, officers assigned to a recipient have to make house visits if payment has not been collected for three months.
If a recipient is found to have moved or died, the name has to be removed from the list immediately.

msn.com

But in Semporna and Sandakan in the Borneo state of Sabah, payments of between RM150 and RM450 in general welfare aid were still being made to 12 dead people, although their deaths had been recorded in the recipients’ list.

google.com

Payments were also made to 154 individuals on whom the department had no information on its database.

msn.com

The Inland Revenue Board (IRB) spent RM9 million to relocate its processing centre from Pandan Indah to Bangi

The Inland Revenue Board (IRB) wasted more than RM9 million in various costs during the relocation of its processing centre from Pandan Indah to Bangi, revealed the 2012 Auditor-General Report.

themalaysianinsider.com

Besides spending RM4.7 million in rental costs, the IRB spent an additional RM505,600 from October 2011 to February 2013 on utility bills and for hiring security firms.

themalaysianinsider.com

The report found that the IRB paid RM529,733 in consultancy fees to four firms, and described the payments as wasteful because the reports issued by these firms could not be used.

themalaysianinsider.com

An additional RM3.27 million was incurred in the course of eight Job Change Orders which had not been approved by the Economic Planning Unit.

themalaysianinsider.com

Schools mishandled RM2.051 billion with regards to hiring security contractors

Schools mishandled RM2.051 billion with regards to hiring security contractors

Image via akamaihd.net

The 2012 Auditor-General’s Report has revealed severe mishandling of RM2.051 billion with regard to hiring security contractors for schools between 2010 and 2012.

malaysiakini.com

From poorly prepared contracts to hiring of septuagenarians as security guards, the auditor-general said the management of security services in 35 schools and hostels surveyed was generally unsatisfactory.

yahoo.com

Nineteen of the 35 facilities visited by the audit team did not have anyone guarding the entrances and people were seen entering and exiting freely.

malaysiakini.com

Read also: Auditor General's report highlighted 5 weaknesses of 7 projects by government statutory bodies

Have something to say about this? Facebook or Tweet us!

Get all latest news here on SAYS (@SAYSdotMY). Tweet us and let us know what's happening around you! We'll feature it on SAYS.

twitter.com

SAYS is Malaysia's social news network. Find today's must-share stories, news and videos everyday, produce and brought to you by Malaysian social media users!

facebook.com

You may be interested in: