Economists Say RM3,100 Living Wage Is Reasonable, But Can Malaysians Actually Live Decently On It?

Follow us on Instagram, TikTok, and WhatsApp for the latest stories and breaking news.

How much does a Malaysian actually need to live a decent life?

The question has become increasingly difficult to answer as housing, food, transport, and other everyday expenses continue to put pressure on household budgets.

Recently, economists said a monthly living wage of RM3,100 was a reasonable baseline for full-time workers, particularly as the cost of living rises.

Universiti Teknologi MARA (UiTM) senior lecturer Dr Mohamad Idham Md Razak told Berita Harian the figure should serve as a minimum reference point to help workers meet their basic needs while maintaining a more dignified standard of living.

He said the benchmark was justified by continued price pressures on food, housing, transport, and other essentials, particularly in urban areas.

The RM3,100 figure is reviewed annually based on changes in the cost of living, using research by the Employees Provident Fund (EPF).

UniKL Business School economist Associate Professor Dr Aimi Zulhazmi Abdul Rashid similarly said RM3,100 was "not a luxurious amount", describing it as a basic calculation for expenses such as rent, food, transport, children's needs, and modest savings in cities including Kuala Lumpur, Selangor, and Penang.

But what does that actually mean for Malaysians living on around RM3,000 a month?

A discussion on Reddit's r/AskMY subreddit asked exactly that, with hundreds of Malaysians sharing how far or how little a RM3,000 salary can stretch.

For some, RM3,000 is enough. For others, it's barely enough.

The discussion produced no clear consensus.

Some said RM3,000 could still provide a decent life for a single person, particularly outside major cities or when living with family.

Others said the same salary was increasingly difficult to live on in Kuala Lumpur and the Klang Valley, especially when rent, transport, and other fixed expenses were involved.

One Redditor who previously earned RM3,500 said they managed to get by while living with their family, although they did not save much.

They cooked rather than ordering food, used public transport, avoided luxury brands, and stopped making unnecessary purchases.

Another commenter said a single person earning RM3,000 could still manage if they were disciplined with their spending.

They suggested using public transport or a motorcycle instead of a car, and estimated that someone living modestly could still save around RM400 to RM500 a month.

But they added that having a car would make things "pretty tight".

RM3,000 looks very different in Klang Valley

For Malaysians living in the Klang Valley, the responses were considerably less optimistic.

One commenter said RM3,000 was "not enough" in KL and Selangor, even for a single person renting only a room rather than an entire home.

Another estimated that someone living alone in the Klang Valley without parental support would need around RM4,500 to RM5,500 just to survive and live an "okay" life, while RM8,000 was when they felt they could start having meaningful financial breathing room.

A Redditor who previously earned around RM3,000 while living alone in Cheras said they had to cover rent, a car loan, and other expenses, leaving them with barely any savings.

They described the salary as "liveable", but said remaining on the same income long-term would make it difficult to improve their lifestyle.

That lines up with UniKL Business School economist Aimi Zulhazmi's assessment that RM3,100 is essentially a basic urban living benchmark rather than a comfortable salary.

He said rising food prices and rents meant RM3,100 today had roughly the same purchasing power as RM2,500 in 2020.

One Malaysian showed exactly how RM3,000 could be budgeted

One of the more detailed Reddit responses broke down what living on RM3,000 could look like for a single person in the Klang Valley.

The commenter said a RM3,000 gross salary would leave around RM2,600 after deductions.

Their monthly budget included:

• RM600 for a small room
• RM50 for public transport
• RM400 for groceries
• RM30 for a phone plan
• RM70 for insurance
• RM100 for PTPTN
• RM150 for entertainment
• RM20 for Netflix
• RM100 for personal care
• RM100 for clothing
• RM200 for their parents

That would leave roughly RM900 for savings and investments.

Adding around RM100 for a gym would bring the potential savings down to around RM700 to RM800.

But the budget came with fairly strict conditions.

The Redditor cooked most of their meals, meal-prepped lunch, bought groceries from cheaper supermarkets and markets, waited for sales when shopping, and kept their hobbies relatively inexpensive.

They described this as a "basic existence" and acknowledged that earning more would be preferable for anyone hoping to buy property, start a family, or achieve other financial goals.

And having a family changes the maths completely

Several Malaysians pointed out that RM3,000 means something very different when it is the sole income supporting a household.

One Redditor said they earned RM3,000 after EPF and Social Security Organisation (PERKESO) deductions and were "barely surviving" in Seremban while supporting a housewife and young son.

Another person earning RM5,000 before EPF and PERKESO deductions said they supported a wife and daughter and could make things work by cutting back on eating out, petrol, and other expenses.

But some households said they could survive on around RM3,000.

One commenter said they earned RM3,000 while supporting a wife and three children.

Their expenses included RM425 for a car, RM700 for their house, around RM250 for bills, RM250 for fuel, and RM400 to RM500 for groceries.

Their relatively low housing cost was possible because they had bought an older single-storey terrace house from their parents.

This highlights one of the biggest variables in the RM3,000 debate: housing costs can completely change the equation.

Outside major cities, however, RM3,000 can stretch further

Location was one of the clearest dividing lines in the Reddit discussion.

Commenters from Kelantan, Terengganu, and Melaka said RM3,000 could still provide a reasonably comfortable life, particularly for single people or those living with family.

One commenter said a single person earning RM3,000 in the East Coast could have a "good life".

Another said RM3,500 was enough to support a non-working wife in Melaka, provided the household was financially conscious and actively kept costs down.

Meanwhile, commenters from Penang and Selangor were considerably more pessimistic.

One person living in Penang said rent for a small family could easily reach RM1,000, meaning a third of a RM3,000 salary could disappear before accounting for food, transport or anything else.

Even RM3,100 isn't supposed to be a comfortable salary

The economists' comments are important here because the RM3,100 figure is not meant to provide workers with much disposable income.

UiTM senior lecturer Idham said it should be treated as a minimum reference point rather than a fixed figure applicable to every worker and every location.

He also said wage increases should at least match, or slightly exceed, annual inflation to prevent workers' real incomes from being eroded.

Aimi Zulhazmi proposed combining inflation and productivity growth when reviewing wages.

For example, if inflation reached 3% and productivity increased by 2%, he said an annual wage adjustment of around 4% to 5% would be reasonable.

For someone earning RM3,100, that would mean an annual increase of approximately RM120 to RM150.

Without regular adjustments, he warned that wages would gradually lose purchasing power as living costs rise.

So, can you actually live a decent life on RM3,000?

The discussion suggests the answer is: yes, but the definition of "decent" matters, and so does where you live.

A single person with cheap accommodation, no major debt, access to public transport and a willingness to cook and limit discretionary spending may still be able to pay their bills and put some money aside.

Someone renting alone in the Klang Valley, paying for a car, and supporting parents or children faces a very different reality.

That may explain why the RM3,100 living-wage benchmark resonates differently with different Malaysians.

For some, it may be enough to cover the basics with careful budgeting.

For others, particularly those living in expensive urban areas or supporting dependants, even RM3,100 may feel like a floor rather than a comfortable income.

And that distinction is perhaps the more useful way to look at the question: RM3,000 may still be enough to survive in Malaysia, but whether it is enough to live well increasingly depends on what you have to pay for before you get to spend anything on actually enjoying your life.